- Payne Beach
- Penfield
- Penfield Center
- Pepper Island
- Pine Meadow Mobile Home Park
- Parsonage Island
- Pearsalls Hassock
- Pine Island (historical)
- Post Marsh
- Peter Cooper Village
- Polo Grounds Houses
- Park Village
- Pleasant Corners
- Pletchers Corners
- Paradise Hill
- Paris
- Paris Station
- Pine
- Pine Crest
- Pine Hill
- Pine Village Estates
- Pleasant Valley
- Point Rock
- Parc du Bois
- Parson Farms
- Peck Hill
- Pine Grove
- Pitcher Hill
- Pleasant View
- Polkville